Toward a Different Debate in Environmental Accounting
The Cases of Carbon and Cost-Benefit

Many champions of environmental accounting suggest that calculating and internalizing 'externalities' is the solution to environmental problems. Many critics of neoliberalism counter that the spread of market-like calculations into 'nonmarket' spheres, is, on the contrary, itself at the root of such problems.

This article in the journal Accounting, Organizations and Society (Volume 34, Issues 3-4, April-May 2009, pages 499-534) proposes setting aside this debate and instead closely examining the concrete conflicts, contradictions and resistances engendered by environmental accounting techniques and the perpetually incomplete efforts of accountants and their allies to overcome them. In particular, it explores how cost-benefit analysis and the carbon accounting techniques required by the Kyoto Protocol, the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme and other carbon trading mechanisms 'frame' new agents, spaces, relations and objects, and what the consequences have been and are likely to be.

Related articles of interest:

• Carbon Trading How It Works and Why It Fails
• Neoliberalism and the Calculable World The Rise of Carbon Trading
• Uncertainty Markets and Carbon Markets Variations on Polanyian Themes
• What Next? Activism, Expertise, Commons
• The Carbon Neutral Myth Offset Indulgences for your Climate Sins
• Carbon Trading A Critical Conversation on Climate Change, Privatisation and Power
• Making and Marketing Carbon Dumps Commodification, Calculation and Counterfactuals in Climate Change Mitigation
• Visitors to the Commons Approaching Thailand’s “Environmental” Struggles from a Western Starting Point
• The Cost-Benefit Analysis Dilemma Strategies and Alternatives
• Ethnic Discrimination in “Global” Conservation
• Cost-Benefit Analysis Whose Interest, Whose Rationality?
• Culture and the Question of Rights
• Whose Voice Is Speaking? How Opinion Polls and Cost-Benefit Analysis Synthesize New “Publics”
• Missing the Point of Development Talk Reflections for Activists
• Mekong Dams in the Drama of Development
• The Globalizers’ Dilemma Contention and Resistance in Intercultural Space